2010年9月11日 星期六

難學又難教

翻開中五的數學課本,發現新高中的數學課程,既難學,又難教。



難學之處,在於因課程時間延長而衍生出來的「深奧」課題。例如排列
(permutation)
,在栗的記憶中,從未在本地數學課程出現過。本來多學一種東西是好事來的,但以今日學生的資質,栗覺得還是多一事不如少一事。



至於難教之處,在於課題分佈不均。例如「續多項式」一課,竟然把指數方程
(exponential equations)
、對數方程 (logarithmic equations) 和三角方程 (trigonometric
equations)
全堆在一起。天呀,有多少學生連基礎對數和三角函數也還未學好,要他們在同一課學了這幾種方程,這不是苦了(補習)老師嗎?



不過方程還算是小事,概率
(probability)
那課中 andor not 的符號,才真的要了栗的命。我到現在還弄不清正U和反U……


7 則留言:

  1. do they also talk about "combination", the cousin of "permutation"?
    [版主回覆09/12/2010 07:56:00]Yes, Teacher. But combination is covered in the Additional Maths syllabus (together with the Binomial Theorem) as long as I can remember. That was why I did not include it in this entry. About the U and inverted U symbols, I recall that they were from the set theorem I learnt in Pure Maths. I don't know why the curriculum include such symbols in the compulsory section. They accepted P (A and B) / P (A or B) in the past!

    回覆刪除
  2. U = universe (omega), or union, like "or" ??

    回覆刪除
  3. 中五? HK math does seem any more advance than US.
    [版主回覆09/14/2010 08:07:00]其實我唔明,點解中國人學數,要比外國人學得更深?

    回覆刪除
  4. 因為英文唔好?  選擇少咗.
    [版主回覆09/15/2010 06:08:00]Maybe.

    回覆刪除
  5. 指數方程 (exponential equations) 、對數方程  (logarithmic equations)  和三角方程 (trigonometric equations) 等 方程, 或然率  (probability)不是中六 ( Advanced Level) 數學嗎?  沒有良好的數學基礎就來這一套,豈非椽木求魚?
    [版主回覆09/15/2010 06:12:00]乏言先生:確實,很多學生的基礎不穩,一次過學三種真的吃不消。 這三種方程一向在會考課程之內,我讀中六、七時,已經要學system of equations, matrix 等課題。 又:現在的新高中課程,甚麼東西都炒埋一碟,令人難受

    回覆刪除
  6. Ok, U is union and inverted U is intersection, yes?

    回覆刪除
  7. 我的記憶法 反U 好像N 所以是AND 有空來交流1下 我也是中學數學老師 mryip06@gmail.com
    [版主回覆01/21/2011 08:17:00]多謝葉 sir 教路, 現在記到了
    會會會, 一定常來交流 :)

    回覆刪除